Arts&Culture | فنون وثقافة

the world of arts and culture       عالم الثقافة و الفنون

Featured | قصص مختارة

selected stories on 7iber       قصص مختارة على حبر

Have Your Say | شو قولك

be part of the conversation… شارك في الحوار

Video | فيديو

Jordan from behind the lens الاردن من ورا العدسه

Wikileaks in Arabic | ويكيليكس بالعربي

translation of cables mentioning jordan ترجمة برقيات التي تذكر الاردن

Home » Arab World, Dailies, Opinions | أراء, Politics

Why I’m Against Annuling the Treaty With Israel

January 3, 2009 206 Comments
610x1 Why Im Against Annuling the Treaty With Israel

Disclaimer: Before making a comment, bear in mind that I am an avid supporter of the Palestinian cause. I have not been “washed away” by Israeli propaganda nor can I begin to explain my fury and frustration at what is going on in Gaza right now.

Written By Farah Nimri

I was reluctant to speak about this at first, because of all the vicious fights that I’ve observed around the blogosphere whenever this subject is discussed. But I’m putting my opinion out there so people can see the other side of the equation. The other opinion, that everybody I’ve met seems to be terrified to disclose.
I am very much against the annulment of the Jordanian-Israeli peace treaty, the closure of the Israeli embassy or the expulsion of the ambassador, and I cannot see what good it could possibly achieve or contribute in ending the massacre the Palestinians are currently facing.

Here’s the thing. I understand the feelings of frustration and anger, I really do. I understand the feeling of helplessness that takes over you as you see the lives of over 400 people – 400 human beings just like you and me – being taken away in a place not so far from what we call home. I understand how the Arab nation feels like something has to be done, something needs to be done, so that we stop feeling so inferior to the rest of the world, to do something after being persecuted for so many years. I understand that it was OUR land to begin with, and that the Israelis were the ones who came here and unrightfully took over what’s not theirs. I understand all of that.

But here’s what I also understand. This dreaded treaty between us and the Israelis, the treaty that protests have been calling to annul for at least three times (that I can remember), is what’s preventing the Israelis from starting a war with us. I honestly don’t understand those who want to go into “war” and start a “jihad” against the Israelis. We are a country of 5 million, we have very few resources, and to put it simply and clearly, there’s no way in hell we can win a war against Israel. The reason Jordan has remained quite a safe country (considering the fact that we live in a war zone), is not exactly a miracle. It’s because we’ve accepted the presence of the Jewish nation as a fact and let’s face it, it’s not going to go away anytime soon, and if you think otherwise, you are either impacted by your emotions, or grossly overestimate the abilities of the very country you’re criticizing.

And this is why I can’t support the riots that have been breaking out all over the place. I couldn’t be more angry about what’s happening, but I frankly think you’re a hypocrite if you tell me you’re willing to sacrifice your freedom and safety to go into a battle, to go into a war, that you KNOW there’s no way you can win. I like the fact that I live in a safe, secure country, where I can go about my daily life without fear of having my house brought down over my head.
This doesn’t mean we’ve given up. I’m not giving up. I make my voice heard to let the people around the world, who aren’t being told the whole story, know that a massacre is taking place. There are other ways we can fight this war, and sacrificing this country is not one of them. We’ve done that once before and lost. We’d just be hitting the self-destruct button.

EDITORS’ NOTE: We would like to note that while 7iber encourages and welcomes all forms of debate, however sensitive the topic may be, it DOES NOT sanction any conversation that is laden with disrespectful language. Please find a way to get your point across without attacking others or their beliefs. Also, please keep it clean: profanity does not strengthen one’s argument.

Thank you.

  • http://www.ups-yours.com/ Universal Package Search

    things havent changed yet

  • http://leftsidepolice.wordpress.com/ Left-sider

    I might disagree with some points in there .. as you cant really call people hypocrites although I believe most are .. but this is not a general form … I like the rational tone though ..

  • http://leftsidepolice.wordpress.com/ Left-sider

    I might disagree with some points in there .. as you cant really call people hypocrites although I believe most are .. but this is not a general form … I like the rational tone though ..

  • ArabThoughts

    Dorte while you’re well within your rights to express your opinion, it is not your place to tell us (i.e. the people of this region) what so-called ‘facts’ we need to recognise. I can’t imagine people in your country accepting an Arab visitor telling them what they should or should not do regarding their domestic affairs. The overwhelming majority of the people in the Middle East will never accept the presence of a foreign and illegitimate occupier on Arab land. That is the fact that you and the world should recognise. It is also utterly disingenuous of you to describe the victim and his oppressor as ‘neighbours’! Please get educated about the matter before rushing off to tell us what you think.

  • ArabThoughts

    The only ‘terrorist’ in this part of the world are the foreign powers that are directly responsible for the deaths of tens of thousands of people i.e. the US and israel. Your comment smacks of ignorance and arrogance. I get the impression that you copy and paste these same comments on different websites without even bothering to read the article beforehand. Its not your place to tell us who the terrorists are – we know all too well who is killing our people.

  • simsim

    I respect the courage it took to write this opinion however I will say that you are a bit off on one claim: the treaty is the only reason Israel is not going to war with us. Really???!!!!! Israel has no respect for any treaty, no matter what it is. Their interests is the main driver in any decision they make.. Also, I agree that we are not as powerful as Israel but I guarantee you they are not the least bit interested in starting a conflict with us this is a time they need friends not new enemies. To further make my point I will remind you that the Palestinians have made some agreements with the Israeli yet they are subject to ruthless Israeli war machine on a daily basis yet Syria who does not have a treaty has not been attacked by the Israel for decades (excpet for one isolated incident).